Quinshon Judkins
Judkins is Cleveland's clear lead back by volume — dominating backfield touches (reportedly 79-80% of RB work, 42 of 47 carries in one week) with Dylan Sampson out — but he's running behind a shaky offensive line and a limited Deshaun Watson offense, producing some of the worst yards-per-carry and yards-before-contact numbers at the position. He's a touch-rich, efficiency-poor RB2/flex whose fantasy value right now is almost entirely role-driven rather than performance-driven.
The two-week arc is volume-versus-efficiency: Rotoworld, Fantasy Focus Football and Fantasy Footballers kept flagging ugly per-carry numbers and six straight sub-11-point games, while FantasyPros, Fantasy Life Show and Yahoo Fantasy Forecast repeatedly pitched him as a buy-low breakout candidate against soft Carolina and Pittsburgh run defenses. That breakout didn't fully arrive, keeping Harris Fantasy Football Podcast and Yahoo's Josh & Hayden bearish on his rankings (RB24, 'worst Round 5 pick') even as The Late-Round Podcast and Dynasty Nerds pointed to rising target share and third-down snaps as a sign the receiving role could eventually bail him out. The September 25 consensus crystallized the split — role is locked in, but the efficiency still hasn't clicked.
The line: Start him for the touches, not the tape — he's a volume-dependent RB2 until the offensive line or passing-game role actually improves.
▶ The Audible: Facing tough sledding behind a depleted offensive line, hasn't topped 4 YPC since last season, but volume keeps him in RB2 range. listen ↗
▼ Fantasy Footballers - Fantasy Football Podcast: Ranked near the bottom of the league in yards per carry, rush success rate, and yards before contact, making him a 'don't mess around with' flex play despite talent. listen ↗
▲ Fantasy Football Today: High-end flex play this week with 17+ touches and a favorable matchup against Pittsburgh's run defense. listen ↗
▲ The Audible: Expected to see increased work after Pittsburgh defense weakened by injuries. listen ↗
▼ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Looking a step slow behind a shaky rebuilt offensive line; hosts call him one of the worst Round 5 picks with only touchdown-dependent flex upside. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Focus Football: Six straight games under 11 fantasy points, averaging 3.0 YPC with no touchdowns and minimal goal-line work; hosts say he must be kept rostered but isn't reliably startable yet. listen ↗
▶ Rotoworld Football Show – Fantasy Football: Dominates Cleveland's backfield touches (42 of 47 carries) but low expected touchdowns and a bad offensive line temper his RB2 case. listen ↗
▶ Dynasty Nerds Podcast | Dynasty Fantasy Football: Still no double-digit fantasy game but looked more involved and the offense is flowing better, so hosts feel less concerned than the raw numbers suggest. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Football Today: Expected to have a good game vs Carolina's poor run defense and expanding passing-game role, but hosts suggested selling high in trades since sustainable role is uncertain; tape hasn't shown same explosiveness as last year. listen ↗
▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Both hosts are heavy on Judkins over 59.5 rushing yards versus Carolina's run defense, and both also picked him for anytime touchdown at plus money, expecting a breakout usage game. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Life Show: Smash-ish spot vs Panthers who allow high RB fantasy points, but concerns remain about Browns' slow pace and low yards after contact. listen ↗
▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Hosts are strongly favoring him this week against a weak Carolina run defense, ranking him six spots higher than consensus and hammering his rushing yardage/attempts props. listen ↗
▶ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Judkins is getting volume but has negative yards before contact and has been compared to 2025 Woody Marks in terms of inefficiency; still preferred by Fitz for role certainty. listen ↗
▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Predicted to top 100 rushing yards and score two touchdowns against Carolina's poor run defense. listen ↗
▲ Yahoo Fantasy Forecast with Matt Harmon: Coming off two tough matchups, hosts view him as a buy-low candidate who should break out against Carolina's weak run defense; ties into a bold prediction he'll produce a top-15 rest-of-season finish. listen ↗
▲ Fantasy Focus Football: Averaging just 2.3 YPC but expected to get going against a Panthers run defense that's allowed big yardage to backs; big bounce-back spot. listen ↗
▲ Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry: Seeing nearly 80% of Browns RB touches and some receiving work; good matchup vs. Panthers run defense. listen ↗
▲ Fantasy Life Show: Effectively a bell-cow with Dylan Sampson out, facing the NFL's second-worst run defense; viewed as a solid RB2 this week. listen ↗
▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Called a buy-low target being acquired cheaply in multiple trade packages, with a promising outlook. listen ↗
▼ Harris Fantasy Football Podcast: Both hosts are lower than consensus on him (ranked RB24) due to lack of efficiency despite volume; still used him in DFS lineups at a discounted price vs Carolina. listen ↗
▶ Dynasty Nerds Podcast | Dynasty Fantasy Football: Got a season-high five targets/receptions with Dylan Sampson injured, but hosts want to see more passing-game involvement; called Week 3 vs. Carolina's weak run defense a pivotal test for his outlook. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Focus Football: Hasn't topped 10.1 fantasy points in five straight games, but a home matchup vs. Carolina (allowing a league-high yards to RBs) is seen as his best breakout chance; hosts say it's 'panic time' if it doesn't happen now. listen ↗
▲ Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry: Has 79% of Browns RB touches and is viewed as a top-20 flex play against a leaky Panthers run defense. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Football Today: Worry-O-Meter ~35-50%; increased route participation and target share are positives, but production still lagging (sub-10 PPR points in a good game script). listen ↗
▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Erickson's biggest bounce-back play of the week, moving him to RB15 (vs ECR 25) due to a plus home matchup vs. Carolina's bad run defense and a three-down role without Dylan Sampson. listen ↗
▶ The Late-Round Fantasy Football Podcast: Route share actually dropped in Week 2 despite more targets, but saw a big uptick in third-and-long snap share (50% vs 17%), suggesting potential for better usage as a receiver going forward. listen ↗
▲ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Called a potential 'sneaky play of the week' vs. a Panthers defense allowing a league-high 6.3 yards per carry, seen as a bold buy-low after two tough opening matchups. listen ↗
▲ Dynasty Nerds Podcast | Dynasty Fantasy Football: Disappointing rushing production so far, but increased target share (5 targets/receptions in Week 2) and a plus matchup vs. Carolina's run defense suggest a breakout could be near; still viewed as long-term lead back. listen ↗
▶ Establish The Run Fantasy Football: 5 catches on just 12 routes after Dylan Sampson's absence; needs to develop pass-game role given inefficiency on the ground (2.3 YPC). listen ↗
▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Faded during draft season, but now seen as a cheap buy-low after tough early matchups; workhorse role solidified with Dylan Sampson on IR and rising target share (16.7% in Week 2). listen ↗
▶ Harris Fantasy Football Podcast: Struggled running up the middle but caught 5 passes as Cleveland shifted to screens; about 50 total scrimmage yards, not great but salvageable via receiving work. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Football Today: Has topped 40% route rate in four straight games and has multiple 4+ target games, but Deshaun Watson's play still limits his overall outlook. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Football Today: Inefficient on the ground (1.8 YPC) but caught 5 passes and saw more third-down snaps; hosts hold but hesitate to start him given offensive line issues. listen ↗
▲ Fantasy Football Today: Preferred start over Dobbins, Kalif Raymond and Malik Nabors due to more upside. listen ↗
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Hosts took the under on 49.5 rushing yards, citing a brutal matchup with Tampa Bay's elite run defense and Cleveland's poor O-line push in Week 1. listen ↗
Follow Quinshon Judkins
Get every take on him — and the rest of your roster — before waivers on Tuesday and before lineups lock on Sunday. Free through the season.
Sign up free