DK Metcalf
Metcalf is Pittsburgh's clear target hog — routinely top-5-10 in air yards and target share — but the volume isn't translating into production, with shows repeatedly flagging drops and a shaky rapport with Aaron Rodgers. Right now he's a boom-or-bust flex/low-end WR2 who draws tough shadow corners nearly every week, making him a name you roster for volume but can't trust as a confident starter.
The two-week arc is remarkably consistent: Fantasy Football Today, Yahoo's Josh & Hayden, Establish The Run, and FantasyPros have hammered the gap between his elite usage (targets, air yards, route share) and his actual output, pointing to drops and shadow coverage from corners like Christian Gonzalez and DJ Turner as the culprits. FantasyPros went furthest, calling him one of the league's most overrated receivers, while The Late-Round Podcast and Fantasy Life pushed back, framing him as a buy-low given the underlying metrics and predicting a breakout is overdue. The lone true contrarian is Fantasy Life, ranking him as high as WR18 off pure usage while nearly every other show downgraded him after each shadow-coverage dud.
The line: Roster him for the target volume, but bench him against shadow corners until the drops and Rodgers chemistry actually turn around.
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Poor efficiency and heavy man coverage usage against elite corners (now Denzel Ward) make hosts wary of a repeat dud performance on Thursday night. listen ↗
▼ Fantasy Footballers - Fantasy Football Podcast: Hosts advised sitting him if possible against Cleveland's tough defense in an ugly, low-scoring matchup. listen ↗
▼ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: Called a sell-low; strong air yards/target volume haven't translated to production due to drops, penalties, and a poor scheme fit with Aaron Rodgers. listen ↗
▶ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: Drew a questionable holding penalty for grabbing a defender, but also scored a touchdown; hosts call him frustrating but productive, per his usual pattern. listen ↗
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Faded under 51.5 receiving yards, citing poor QB play from Aaron Rodgers, low separation, and a tougher Bengals matchup; hasn't topped 51 yards in any Steelers game yet. listen ↗
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Debro won't start him, expecting a shutdown shadow from CB DJ Turner who limited him to under 50 yards and no TDs in both meetings last year. listen ↗
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Expected to be shadowed by DJ Turner, who held him under 50 yards in both matchups last year, making him a fade this week. listen ↗
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Coming off an abysmal performance in a struggling Steelers offense; hosts won't trust him in a flex spot right now. listen ↗
▼ Fantasy Focus Football: Facing likely shadow coverage from DJ Turner, who held him under 10 fantasy points in both matchups last year; hosts are worried given his already poor chemistry with Aaron Rodgers. listen ↗
▼ Fantasy Football Today: Expected to be shadowed again (this time by DJ Turner after struggling vs. Christian Gonzalez), with poor underlying target/air-yard share metrics; barely a three-WR-league starter. listen ↗
▲ Fantasy Life Show: Elite utilization (100% route rate, 19 targets) despite poor box score production; hosts believe a breakout game is coming, ranking him as high as WR18. listen ↗
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Called 'one of the most overrated wide receivers in the NFL' after struggling against a Patriots corner. listen ↗
▼ The Audible: Hosts joke he's underperforming his $30M salary and doing little for Pittsburgh's stagnant offense. listen ↗
▼ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Struggling badly in isolated man coverage and dropping passes as Pittsburgh's passing offense ranks last in EPA under Aaron Rodgers. listen ↗
▼ Establish The Run Fantasy Football: Part of a passing game that's 0-for-9 on 20+ yard throws this season with Aaron Rodgers; some drops noted but overall lack of downfield production. listen ↗
▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Not living up to his contract/hype; easily taken out of games by a shadow cornerback. listen ↗
▶ RotoWire Fantasy Football With Theo Gremminger: Referred to as Puka Nacua context error aside; not directly covered separately. listen ↗
▼ Establish The Run Fantasy Football: Started at 5,200 against the Patriots in cash; Levitan called this a mistake in hindsight. listen ↗
▼ Fantasy Feast: NFL Fantasy Football Podcast: Struggled badly in the Steelers' offense, described as 'not okay' with something clearly wrong. listen ↗
▼ Fantasy Footballers - Fantasy Football Podcast: 9-10 targets over two weeks producing very few yards despite being open repeatedly; hosts say he leads the NFL in negative fantasy-points differential versus expectation but still must be rostered given target volume. listen ↗
▼ Fantasy Football Today: Tied for 4th in targets through two weeks but has been plagued by drops (dubbed 'the DK Metcalfs'); seen as a decent trade throw-in but not a priority pickup. listen ↗
▼ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: Dropping passes repeatedly and looking like a poor fit with Aaron Rodgers after thriving with Russell Wilson's deep-ball style in Seattle. listen ↗
▼ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Only 4 catches for 27 yards on 9 targets, with multiple drops while shadowed by Christian Gonzalez; hosts say he's simply not a true WR1 anymore. listen ↗
▼ Yahoo Fantasy Forecast with Matt Harmon: 9 targets but only 4 catches for 27 yards with multiple drops; hosts say the underlying metrics don't match his real usefulness given shadow coverage and low-percentage routes from Aaron Rodgers. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Football Today: With CB Joey Porter out, hosts see him as a low-end WR2/high-end WR3 with upside but risk of being shut down by Christian Gonzalez. listen ↗
▶ The Late-Round Fantasy Football Podcast: Underperformed his expected points in week one despite strong air yards and target depth; facing Christian Gonzalez this week is viewed as a tough shadow-coverage matchup. listen ↗
Follow DK Metcalf
Get every take on him — and the rest of your roster — before waivers on Tuesday and before lineups lock on Sunday. Free through the season.
Sign up free