David Montgomery

RB, HOU

Montgomery is Houston's lead back on paper but he's been ground down by a bad offensive line and a rising role for Woody Marks, including lost goal-line work. He opened the season with a touchdown bonanza in Week 1 but has been largely inefficient since, making him touchdown-dependent rather than a true volume workhorse right now.

The arc is stark: after a three-TD Week 1 explosion, nearly every show (Yahoo's Harmon, FantasyPros, RotoWire, Fantasy Football Today, The Ringer, Dynasty Nerds) pivoted hard to 'sell high' by Week 2's 4.4-point dud, and that consensus hardened through Week 3 as his YPC cratered to the 2-3 range and Woody Marks visibly ate into red-zone work. A brief counter-wave (Fantasy Football Today, Berry's Happy Hour, The Audible, Fantasy Footballers) pushed him as a bounce-back/start-of-the-week play against bad run defenses like the Colts, but even those takes hedged on his touchdown-dependent volatility. By late September the disagreement has essentially collapsed — shows that once debated sell-high timing now agree the window may already be closed.

The line: Sell if any buyer remains, otherwise bench him as a touchdown-only RB3 until Houston's line and Marks split get sorted. · updated Oct 01

Thursday, October 1

▼ Yahoo Fantasy Forecast with Matt Harmon: Hosts call him a 'great sell high' after a touchdown-driven week one; recommend trading him due to poor fit/reads in the current scheme. listen ↗

Wednesday, September 30

▶ Fantasy Focus Football: Preferred over Ladd McConkie in flex questions and seen as a fringe RB1 regardless of Nico Collins' health status for Houston. listen ↗

▼ The Audible: Not getting the elite workload some expected; Woody Marks remains a competing factor in the backfield. listen ↗

▲ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Nico Collins' return should unlock more goal-line work in a good matchup vs a rookie-heavy Cowboys defense, despite season-long O-line struggles. listen ↗

▼ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Extremely inefficient (lowest rate of 5+ yard carries in the NFL); Josh says he'd trade him straight up for Bhayshul Tuten in his own league. listen ↗

Tuesday, September 29

Both shows agree the Texans backfield situation has soured hard — poor line play, cratering efficiency, and Woody Marks eating into goal-line touches leave Montgomery as a touchdown-dependent RB3 at best. No disagreement here: sell high if you can, and don't trust him as a confident lineup start until the offense stabilizes.

▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Efficiency has cratered (2.8 YPC, low success rate) and Woody Marks is stealing goal-line work; hosts regret not selling after his Week 1 three-TD game and still recommend selling now, citing upcoming Dallas/Tennessee matchups as trade bait. listen ↗

▼ RotoWire Fantasy Football With Theo Gremminger: Inefficient and touchdown-dependent without Nico Collins; sell candidate before the market catches up to his poor underlying production. listen ↗

▼ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Struggling badly behind a poor offensive line with low yards-per-carry and few explosive runs; losing goal-line work to Woody Marks. listen ↗

▼ Yahoo Fantasy Forecast with Matt Harmon: Total panic amid a struggling Texans offense without Nico Collins/Jaden Higgins; now viewed as a touchdown-dependent RB3. listen ↗

Monday, September 28

Both shows agree Montgomery is fading fast — three straight weeks of sub-par efficiency, goal-line work bleeding to Woody Marks, and no clear path back to relevance. Bench him and look elsewhere; any sell-high value is gone.

▼ Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry: Averaging just 2.8 yards per carry with almost no explosive runs and under 6 fantasy points per game the last two weeks, though schedule softens ahead. listen ↗

▼ Fantasy Football Today: Continued poor rushing efficiency (3 YPC) for third straight week and lost two goal-line carries to Woody Marks; hosts say sell-high window may be gone. listen ↗

▼ Harris Fantasy Football Podcast: Got stuffed repeatedly and lost snaps to Woody Marks; hosts said he's more a passenger than a driver in a struggling offense. listen ↗

▼ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: 11 carries for 33 yards, now splitting touches with Woody Marks with no clear role; labeled a 'shart' with declining trust. listen ↗

Saturday, September 26

▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Bounced from RB6 to RB48 across two weeks; hosts lean toward a strong performance against the league's worst run defense (Colts) but flag touchdown-dependent volatility and a game-script sensitive role split with Woody Marks. listen ↗

Friday, September 25

▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Hosts recommend trading him away (for pieces like Xavier Legette or DK Metcalf) especially if he scores again this week against a bad Colts defense, citing inefficient usage and Woody Marks' rising role. listen ↗

▲ RotoWire Fantasy Football With Theo Gremminger: Flagged as a bounce-back candidate if Houston can control the game script and lean on the run against a weak Colts run defense. listen ↗

▲ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: Struggled last week (10 rush yards) but hosts still like him against a Colts defense allowing the most yards in the NFL in a decade. listen ↗

Thursday, September 24

▲ Fantasy Footballers - Fantasy Football Podcast: Named start of the week off a down game, citing a plus matchup against a run defense ranked 30th/31st in key efficiency metrics. listen ↗

▲ Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry: Expected heavy workload against a Colts defense allowing second-most rushing yards to RBs. listen ↗

▲ Fantasy Football Today: Splitting third-down work fairly evenly with Woody Marks but still viewed ahead of committee backs like Tuten/Stevenson/Judkins against a bad Colts run defense. listen ↗

▼ RotoWire Fantasy Football With Theo Gremminger: Recap of prior recommendation to sell high after Week 1 explosion; validated since Woody Marks-like role (Jahmyr Gibbs) cut into his usage in Week 2. listen ↗

Wednesday, September 23

▼ Dynasty Nerds Podcast | Dynasty Fantasy Football: Went from a three-touchdown, 28.9-point Week 1 to just 4.4 points in Week 2, losing snaps, targets and red-zone work to Woody Marks; hosts leaned toward him settling in as a touchdown-dependent, low-double-digit scorer. listen ↗

▶ The Audible: Expected to get touchdown opportunities despite poor run-blocking, due to Indy's defensive tendencies. listen ↗

Tuesday, September 22

▶ Fantasy Life Show: Poor Week 2 output (4.4 points) in a negative game script; hosts see this as a sell-high candidate rather than buy-low, expecting rebound once Nico Collins returns. listen ↗

▼ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Called a sell given offensive line issues and Nico Collins' absence hurting the Texans' offense, with hosts regretting not selling him sooner. listen ↗

Monday, September 21

Both shows flag the same red flag: after a hot Week 1, Montgomery all but disappeared in Week 2, held to 6 carries for 10 yards and 2 catches as Houston's offense stalled in third-and-long situations against a stout run defense. No disagreement here—treat last week's outburst as the outlier and temper expectations until the offensive line and game script improve.

▼ Fantasy Focus Football: Managed just 10 yards on six carries; hosts reaffirm their call that he was a correct sell-high candidate after his big Week 1. listen ↗

▶ Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry: Only 52% snap share and 4.4 fantasy points in Week 2 without Nico Collins, but hosts call it noise and still view him as a mid-tier RB2 given upcoming soft schedule. listen ↗

▼ Fantasy Football Today: Only 6 carries for 10 yards and 2 catches despite being started in 92% of leagues; hosts cite a tough Bengals run defense and inefficiency as concerns. listen ↗

▼ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: Had 3 TDs week one but was nearly invisible in Week 2 with the Texans stuck in third-and-long; hosts fear this week's dud is closer to his real production level. listen ↗

Sunday, September 20

▲ The Audible: Both hosts like him as a GPP play with Nico Collins out, dominating touches roughly 70-30 over Woody Marks with 100% of red zone carries vs Cincinnati. listen ↗

Follow David Montgomery

Get every take on him — and the rest of your roster — before waivers on Tuesday and before lineups lock on Sunday. Free through the season.