Caleb Williams
Williams enters year two in Chicago as the quarterback of Ben Johnson's new offense, positioned as a mid-tier QB1 with QB1-overall upside if the scheme boost outweighs his rookie-year accuracy and red-zone issues. He's an asset defined by scheme optimism colliding with real statistical red flags from last season.
The two-week arc is bullish on the Ben Johnson hire but split on how much it fixes Williams. Yahoo's Matt Harmon and The Ringer's Mina Kimes lead the optimist camp, with Kimes calling any ranking of Tua above him unjustifiable and pushing him toward top-four QB status; FantasyPros and Fantasy Focus Football's Liz Loza counter by pointing to his 31st-ranked red-zone touchdown rate and 32nd-ranked completion percentage last year, with FantasyPros ranking him behind Jayden Daniels on accuracy and lesser rushing equity. Fantasy Focus's Daniel sits in the middle at QB9, essentially betting on Johnson's scheme to paper over the efficiency problems.
The line: Draft Williams as a QB9-ish scheme bet, not a top-four lock — the accuracy and red-zone issues are legitimate, unresolved risk.
▲ Yahoo Fantasy Forecast with Matt Harmon: Green light; Ben Johnson's offense projected as a potential top-five fantasy offense if injuries to Burden/Odunze aren't severe. listen ↗
▲ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: Ranked No. 9; Mina Kimes called Tua ranking above him 'one of the greatest miscarriages of justice,' arguing Caleb should be top-four caliber. listen ↗
▶ Fantasy Focus Football: Daniel has him as high as QB9 citing year-two growth under Ben Johnson, but Liz flags consistency issues (31st in red zone TD%, 32nd in completion %). listen ↗
▶ FantasyPros Football Podcast: Hosts like his pairing with Ben Johnson and improvisational arm talent but rank him behind Jayden Daniels due to accuracy concerns and less rushing production. listen ↗
Follow Caleb Williams
Get every take on him — and the rest of your roster — before waivers on Tuesday and before lineups lock on Sunday. Free through the season.
Sign up free