Play Action
We listen to every fantasy football podcast. You read the takes.
Yahoo Fantasy Forecast with Matt Harmon · Wednesday, September 23

10 Fantasy Data Points you need to know for Week 3

Listen to the episode ↗

Matt Harmon and Ray Garvin open with grim quarterback news (Jackson Dart facing likely season-ending knee surgery, Caleb Williams in concussion protocol) before running through ten fantasy data points for Week 3, centered on which offenses' scheme and personnel usage (under-center run game, play-action, motion) are translating into real fantasy production versus which are schematically sound but not yet converting. They close with a recap of their Yahoo Expert League standings.

This episode of Yahoo Fantasy Forecast opens with grim quarterback news before Matt Harmon and Ray Garvin run through their weekly "10 stats you need to know" data dump. The through-line of the show is that offensive scheme and personnel usage — under-center rate, play-action efficiency, motion, target concentration — are better predictors of fantasy value right now than box scores from the first two weeks, and several teams doing everything schematically right just haven't gotten paid off yet.

The arguments

Jackson Dart's injury is a serious blow to the Giants offense, and Malik Nabors' fantasy outlook has gotten murkier, not better. Harmon and Garvin both note Dart may need season-ending knee surgery, and while a Jameis Winston-Nabors connection sounds appealing on paper, Winston looked shaky Monday night and Nabors is still working back from his own injury and now dealing with a shoulder issue. Garvin adds that the Giants dropped from using heavy personnel (6th in Week 1) to a more spread-out, undefined offensive identity in Week 2, and both hosts worry the Week 1 win now looks like a mirage.

Case Keenum likely starting for the Bears this week is bad news for all Chicago pass catchers. With Caleb Williams in the concussion protocol, Garvin pulls Keenum's atrocious final two 2023 starts (including a 3.6 YPA game) as a red flag. Both hosts agree there's no scenario where you feel good starting Luther Burden, Rome Odunze, or even Colston Loveland this week, though Garvin says he's not fully panicking on Loveland long-term.

Bryce Young's Panthers offense, now run by Brad Idzik instead of Dave Canales, is quietly one of the better fantasy environments in the league. Garvin's creativity/opportunity model has Carolina 13th in offensive creativity but 3rd in expected fantasy points per play, with receivers getting 53% of expected fantasy points. Harmon backs this with his own model (13th in static score, 4th in pace score) and both agree Tetairoa McMillan and Jalen Coker are already playing like top-24 fantasy receivers, with Darren Waller (3% rostered) a viable streaming tight end purely for touchdown equity given his red-zone role.

The Eagles have become a de facto wide-receiver-only offense because the offensive line and run game are broken. Harmon cites Philadelphia running 11 personnel on 76% of snaps (trailing only Tampa Bay) and nearly 90% on passing downs, with DeVonta Smith, Jaelan Phillips-blocking specialist Xavier... actually Ray Garvin and Harmon focus on Smith (96% routes), Makai Lemon (81%), and Dontayvion Wicks (79%) as the only real rotation, while 48% of Eagles carries have gone for two yards or less. Both agree Lemon is a bench stash for the second half of the season since he's barely used in two-receiver sets, while Smith is a top-five weekly receiver and Wicks (2.49 YPRR) is a legitimate flex.

Travis Kelce is playing some of his best football since 2022, and it's real. Garvin flags Kelce's 16 targets, 12 catches, 172 yards through two weeks as a near-exact match to his 2022 pace, with a nearly 26% target share and elite usage score in Week 2. Harmon adds that Kelce is getting more short-area layup targets than Rashee Rice this year, tying into his prior concern that Rice would regress, and both rank Kelce inside their top-six tight ends currently, boosted further by a plus Dolphins matchup.

Josh Downs' role change in Indianapolis is fully established, and he's a locked-in weekly starter. Harmon notes Downs is running routes on 93% of dropbacks (a career high by a wide margin) and leads the NFL in separation score, while Garvin points out Indy even uses him in 12 personnel. Both want to see his route tree stretched downfield rather than relying on quick slants, but agree he's an every-week play as long as he's healthy.

Denzel Boston looks like the best rookie receiver in his class, operating almost entirely as a pure X receiver. Garvin highlights Boston's 93% snap share and 85% route share against KC Concepcion's more limited role, plus a 23% target share and 56% air-yard share in Week 2. Harmon agrees, ranking him ahead of several receivers on his dynasty board and floating him as a possible team leader in receiving yards for Cleveland this season, with both noting the lack of competition from Jerry Jeudy or other Browns pass catchers.

What it means for your roster

  • Add Darren Waller (3% rostered) if you're streaming tight end — chase his red-zone role in Carolina's Bryce Young-led offense, not target volume.
  • Bench/avoid Bears pass catchers (Burden, Odunze, Loveland) this week with Case Keenum likely starting; don't overreact on Loveland long-term per Garvin.
  • Start DeVonta Smith as a top-five WR and consider Dontayvion Wicks as a flex against the Bears; hold Makai Lemon as a bench stash, not a Week 3 starter.
  • Play Travis Kelce as a top-six fantasy tight end, especially in a plus Dolphins matchup, with Kenneth Walker (not Rashee Rice) as the offense's other short-area beneficiary.
  • Start Josh Downs every week; monitor Tyler Warren for a more expansive route tree before trusting him as a touchdown-dependent play.
  • Buy Denzel Boston now if available in dynasty/keeper formats — both hosts have him rated ahead of several higher-drafted rookies and see leading-receiver upside on the Browns.
  • Reconsider Bryce Young as a startable QB1 in 10-12 team leagues for the next two weeks (vs. Cleveland and Detroit) before Carolina's Week 5 bye.
“Happy wife. Happy life. That's what I've heard.” — Ray Garvin

Players in this episode

Kenneth Walker · RB, KC

↑ Leading the team with 11 targets of five or fewer air yards, becoming a key receiving-game piece and 'change force' pulling volume from Rice.

Caleb Williams · QB, CHI

↓ In the concussion protocol, likely paving the way for Case Keenum to start, which is bad news for Bears pass catchers.

Malik Nabers · WR, NYG

↓ Dealing with a shoulder issue and still not fully himself post-injury; hosts are less optimistic about his outlook now that Winston looked shaky and Dart is hurt.

Rashee Rice · WR, KC

↓ Losing short-area target volume to Kenneth Walker and Travis Kelce, confirming preseason concerns about his role changing.

Justin Herbert · QB, LAC

↓ Scored fewer than 10 fantasy points and is seen as needing to play better for the Chargers passing game (and Ladd McConkey/Emeka Egbuka) to live up to its usage-based expectations.

DeVonta Smith · WR, PHI

↑ Running a route on 96% of dropbacks and playing like a top-five receiver as the Eagles shift to a pass-heavy, 11-personnel offense due to their struggling run game.

Tetairoa McMillan · WR, CAR

↑ Playing like a top-24 receiver already, benefiting from Carolina's aggressive, big-receiver-friendly scheme.

Jaxson Dart · QB, NYG

↓ New testing revealed his knee injury is worse than initially thought, with a real possibility of season-ending surgery, a major blow to the Giants offense.

Bhayshul Tuten · RB, JAX

↑ Holds a 60% RB touch share and dominates goal-line work (100% of touches inside the 2), making him a solid RB2 despite minimal receiving usage; expected to improve as backfield 'gnats' are phased out.

Tyler Warren · TE, IND

→ Usage has been short-area/limited so far; hosts want to see a more expansive route tree and more downfield targets rather than panic on him.

Travis Kelce · TE, KC

↑ Off to a start nearly identical to his huge 2022 season (16 targets, 172 yards through two weeks), now the primary short-area target getter over Rashee Rice and playing with elite route speed.

Makai Lemon · WR, PHI

↓ Playing zero snaps in two-receiver sets and mainly used as a blocker/slot piece; deemed a bench hold and back-half-of-season stash rather than a startable option now.

Josh Downs · WR, IND

↑ Role has fully changed with a 93% route share, leading all Colts receivers and running routes even in 12 personnel; considered an every-week fantasy starter.

Jalen Coker · WR, CAR

↑ Alongside McMillan, viewed as a near top-24 receiver given the concentrated target share in Carolina's passing offense.

Bryce Young · QB, CAR

↑ Playing at a high level in an offense now called by Brad Idzik; ranked as a firmly startable QB (roughly QB14) for the next two weeks against Cleveland and Detroit.

Denzel Boston · WR, CLE

↑ Leading all rookie receivers with a 93% snap share and 154 receiving yards, deployed as a true X receiver running downfield routes; viewed as a strong dynasty buy and possibly Cleveland's leading receiver this season.

Dontayvion Wicks · WR, PHI

↑ Averaging 2.49 yards per route run through two weeks as an efficient big-play option and viable flex play as long as his route share holds.

Darren Waller · TE, CAR

↑ Involved in the red zone in back-to-back weeks (two TDs in Week 2, one called back in Week 1); a viable, lightly-rostered streaming option if you're desperate at tight end.

Jameis Winston · QB, NYG

↓ Looked uninspiring on Monday Night Football with his arm strength appearing diminished on several throws, tempering hopes he'd pepper Nabors with targets.

Case Keenum · QB, CHI

↓ Hasn't thrown a pass since December 2023 and looked poor in his last outings; hosts are pessimistic about him elevating Bears receivers against Philadelphia.

← Back to the pods feed