J.J. McCarthy

QB, MIN

McCarthy entered camp as Minnesota's presumed starter but has lost the job to Kyler Murray, leaving him as a bench asset with fringe dynasty/Superflex relevance tied to draft capital rather than performance.

The arc over the past two weeks is a steady slide: Rotoworld, RotoWire, and The Audible all report he's lost the competition, with The Audible going furthest by questioning whether he can play at NFL speed at all. Establish The Run and Fantasy Feast offer the lone counterpoint, noting he's reportedly outplayed Murray in practice and remains a real in-season contingency given the Vikings' investment in him. Fantasy Focus splits the difference, treating the competition as genuine but expecting Murray to open as starter.

The line: Stash only in deep Superflex leagues as free insurance—he's not startable and may not even be the backup plan that matters most. · updated Aug 13

Wednesday, September 30

▼ Establish The Run Fantasy Football: Traded to the Giants, expected to take over as starter after the Week 8 bye; historically has a poor catchable target rate, which tanked Justin Jefferson's output last year and worries hosts for Giants pass catchers. listen ↗

▶ The Audible: Traded to the Giants; hosts say move isn't impactful for fantasy, more interesting for Minnesota's side; Giants didn't trade for him to sit behind Winston long-term. listen ↗

Tuesday, September 29

Now a Giant after being dealt for a mere 2027 fifth-rounder, with every show agreeing he backs up Jameis Winston for now but eventually takes over — the debate is just timing, with some eyeing a Week 5 shot if Jameis falters and Harmon's crew doubting he's even ready for a real long-term look. Stash him in dynasty and deep redraft leagues, but he's unrosterable in shallow formats until Winston actually implodes.

▶ Establish The Run Fantasy Football: Acquired via trade for a fifth-round pick; hosts expect Jameis Winston to keep starting until the Giants lose a couple more games, then McCarthy takes over. listen ↗

▶ Fantasy Feast: NFL Fantasy Football Podcast: Giants traded a fifth-round pick to acquire him, giving them another young quarterback option alongside Jaxson Dart and Jameis Winston. listen ↗

▶ Fantasy Life Show: Traded from Vikings to Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick; Scott Turner says he could see the field if Jameis Winston struggles further, calling the Giants move a bit of a panic deal. listen ↗

▶ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Hosts debate his timeline; think Giants won't rush him in given lack of reps and rapport, projecting a possible start against Washington in Week 5 if Jameis struggles, with the Giants likely giving him extended run afterward. listen ↗

▲ FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast: Traded from Minnesota to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick; hosts argue he was never given a fair shake in Minnesota and his per-dropback numbers compare favorably to Caleb Williams and Bo Nix; expected to start around Week 5 for the Giants. listen ↗

▲ Rotoworld Football Show – Fantasy Football: Beat writer report suggests he'll likely start soon for the Giants after the trade, with hosts agreeing he should get a real look given how poorly Jameis Winston has played. listen ↗

▶ The Audible: Traded and expected to start within a month per Cecil, reuniting with Harbaugh; seen as a game-manager fit for a run-heavy offense, unlike his failed fit under Kevin O'Connell. listen ↗

▶ The Audible: Traded from Minnesota to the Giants for a fifth-round pick; hosts view it as the Vikings admitting a draft mistake, and expect McCarthy could eventually start for the Giants over Jameis Winston. listen ↗

▶ The Ringer Fantasy Football Show: Traded from Minnesota to New York for a 5th-round pick; hosts see it as a low-risk dart throw as a backup, with the Vikings moving on after Kyler Murray struggled. listen ↗

▶ Yahoo Fantasy Football with Josh & Hayden: Traded to the Giants for a 5th-round pick but reportedly slated to back up Jameis Winston; hosts are skeptical of immediate fantasy value but think he'll eventually start. listen ↗

▼ Yahoo Fantasy Forecast with Matt Harmon: Traded from Minnesota to the Giants for a 2027 5th-round pick; hosts skeptical he's ready for a legitimate long-term starting shot in New York. listen ↗

Monday, September 28

▲ Fantasy Footballers - Fantasy Football Podcast: Traded from Minnesota to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick; hosts see it as a real dynasty uptick since he now has a path to start, though he likely won't start immediately. listen ↗

▶ Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry: Traded to the Giants; unlikely to have immediate fantasy impact as he'll need weeks before starting. listen ↗

▶ Fantasy Football Today: Acquired for a fifth-round pick; could take over if Jameis Winston keeps struggling, but offense likely remains conservative even if he plays. listen ↗

Tuesday, September 22

▶ Fantasy Football Today: A New York media columnist suggested the Giants trade for him, but hosts are skeptical Minnesota would deal him and think the Giants would rather stick with Winston given his contract. listen ↗

Follow J.J. McCarthy

Get every take on him — and the rest of your roster — before waivers on Tuesday and before lineups lock on Sunday. Free through the season.