Play Action
We listen to every fantasy football podcast. You read the takes.
RotoWire Fantasy Football With Theo Gremminger · Monday, September 28

10 BIGGEST Fantasy Football Takeaways from Week 3

Listen to the episode ↗

Theo Gremminger recaps Week 3, highlighting historically elite performances from Jahmyr Gibbs and a huge win-rate gap for top-pick drafters, breakout games from Bijan Robinson, Drake London/Michael Penix, and Brock Bowers, plus a Green Bay passing funnel despite a broken offensive line. He also covers concerning trends like Drake May's turnovers, the Patriots' collapse, and a rash of injuries (Justin Jefferson, Devon Achane, Garrett Wilson, Mike Evans).

This week-three recap runs through ten fantasy takeaways, but the throughline is that the top of the running back and tight end pool has separated hard from the field while Green Bay's offensive line collapse and a wave of injuries reshuffle the waiver picture. Theo repeatedly frames this as a "win rate" problem: teams that landed elite volume players are pulling away, and everyone else needs to hunt for the next tier of opportunity.

The arguments

Jahmyr Gibbs has turned into an unprecedented cheat code that's already deciding leagues. Gibbs is averaging over 30 PPR points a game with six touchdowns and 18 catches, five more than the next-closest back (CMC's 13). Theo argues this isn't hyperbole — it's genuinely one of the best running back starts ever — and that any manager who drafted Gibbs first overall is now sitting on a near-unbeatable weekly floor.

Michael Penix's return validates the Penix/Drake London correlation the hosts flagged all summer. London was quiet through two weeks with Penix out, then exploded for 9 catches, 194 yards and 28 points once Penix started against Green Bay. The hosts treat this as confirmation, not surprise, and say London should be started as a locked-in WR1 in any week Penix is under center.

Bijan Robinson's role fears are overblown — the offensive environment, not touches, was the issue. After discourse about Kenneth Walker cutting into his workload, Bijan got 29 carries for 194 yards and two touchdowns plus two catches against Green Bay. Theo says this was as much about how Bijan looked as the raw stats, and pairs it with genuine optimism that Atlanta (with a winnable game vs. New Orleans next) could rattle off wins.

Green Bay's offensive line is historically bad, but that's accidentally created a must-start receiver duo. The Packers have the fewest rushing yards through three games since 1933, which Theo says will likely push Dan Fornick's offensive line rankings to dead last. That funnels volume to Christian Watson (back-to-back double-digit target games, now an unquestioned WR1) and Matthew Golden (two 12-target games in three weeks), a receiver Theo says he took heat for backing in dynasty circles last year.

JSN is operating on a different plane and Seattle's backfield can't be trusted. JSN is averaging 35 points a game and pulling further ahead of Amon-Ra St. Brown as the league's clear WR1, even torching a bad Washington secondary in garbage time. But Seattle went to a true committee backfield, burning Jadarian Price managers, and Sam Darnold's four-touchdown day (with two picks) is framed as a plus for JSN more than a signal to chase Darnold himself.

Jeremiah Love finally broke out, and the usage metrics suggest it's sustainable. After two weeks of poor snap and route rates despite strong efficiency marks (yards after contact, missed tackle rate), Love posted 21 carries for 90 yards, 5 catches for 19 yards and a touchdown — good for RB4 on the week. The hosts see Arizona's competitive showing as a sign the offense and Love's role are trending up together.

Clint Kubiak and Brock Bowers have turned Las Vegas into the week's biggest story, and Kirk Cousins is buying time before the Fernando Mendoza transition. Cousins has nine touchdown passes in three games behind Kubiak's play-calling, and Bowers returned from a rest-day scare with 13 targets, 10 catches, 116 yards, a score and a 43% target share. Theo frames Cousins' hot start as a countdown clock rather than a threat to dynasty Mendoza stashes, since the floor could still fall out.

Jalen Warren's takeover game and Drake May's historic turnover pace are the two clearest roster-action signals of the week. Warren dominated touches with Roschon Johnson out, going for over 20 PPR points on 127 rushing yards and 49 receiving yards, prompting Theo to say managers should be actively upgrading him. Meanwhile Drake May has turned the ball over seven times in three weeks (a stat matched only by Will Levis since 2022) and is labeled an outright bench in a blowout loss to Jacksonville.

What it means for your roster

  • Hold, don't panic-sell any Gibbs/JSN/Bowers-anchored team — the hosts view these as legitimate weekly floors that separate contenders from the pack.
  • Start Drake London as a locked-in WR1 in every game Penix starts; the split is described as career-long and real, not a one-game blip.
  • Prioritize Christian Watson and Matthew Golden as start-every-week assets out of Green Bay's forced pass-funnel offense, even with the team's overall outlook bleak.
  • Bench Drake May entirely until turnover issues improve — no redeeming metric to hang optimism on right now.
  • Waiver priority for Miami backfield: grab both Braylon Allen and Ollie Gordon off waivers with Devon Achane's knee injury; Theo ranks Allen ahead of Gordon if forced to choose one.
  • Buy/upgrade Jalen Warren in trade talks off his 20+ point workhorse game, and monitor Michael Wilson as a viable FLEX/WR3 given his rapport with Jacoby Brissett and a 17-target week.
“Jameer Gibbs is on another planet.” — Theo Gremminger

Players in this episode

Jahmyr Gibbs · RB, DET

↑ Averaging over 30 PPG with 6 TDs and an NFL-leading 18 catches for a RB, called a true cheat code and one of the best RB starts ever.

Bijan Robinson · RB, ATL

↑ Had 29 carries for 194 yards and two TDs plus two catches vs Green Bay, easing concerns about offensive environment holding him back.

Ja'Marr Chase · WR, CIN

↑ Posted 9 catches, 98 yards and a TD, with 3 TD grabs and back-to-back 20+ point games.

Jaxon Smith-Njigba · WR, SEA

↑ Averaging 35 PPG and pulling away as clear WR1 over Amon-Ra St. Brown, dominating even against a bad Washington secondary.

De'Von Achane · RB, MIA

↓ Suffered a knee injury with the team not optimistic, creating a big downgrade for Miami's backfield.

Drake Maye · QB, NE

↓ Has 7 turnovers through 3 weeks (worst since 2022 alongside Will Levis) and looks lost; labeled a bench-until-proven-otherwise QB after a 35-6 blowout loss.

Chase Brown · RB, CIN

↓ Disappointed with fewer than 10 PPR points in a game the hosts expected him to produce.

Justin Jefferson · WR, MIN

↓ Left the game with an ankle injury.

Jeremiyah Love · RB, ARI

↑ Broke out with career highs: 21 carries for 90 yards, 5 catches for 19 yards and a TD, finishing as RB4 on the week and signaling a usage uptick after a slow start.

Drake London · WR, ATL

↑ Exploded for 9 catches, 194 yards and 28 points with Penix back, continuing his career-long trend of performing much better with Penix starting.

Josh Jacobs · RB, GB

↓ Not viewed as the answer to Green Bay's rushing woes given the poor offensive line play.

Brock Bowers · TE, LV

↑ Returned from a rest-day scare to post 10 catches for 116 yards, a TD, and a 43% target share, cementing him as the TE1 overall.

Breece Hall · RB, NYJ

↓ Suffered a thigh injury, making Braylon Allen a priority waiver add.

Garrett Wilson · WR, NYJ

↓ In concussion protocol, potentially out next week.

Jadarian Price · RB, SEA

↓ Seattle used a true committee backfield, making the RB room unreliable and a disappointing start for Price.

Jaylen Warren · RB, PIT

↑ Dominated with Rico Dowdle out, posting 127 rushing yards, 49 receiving yards and over 20 PPR points, outplaying Bengals counterpart Chase Brown.

Brock Purdy · QB, SF

↑ Threw 4 TD passes and has scored at least 2 (often 3) passing TDs every game this season, looking dominant regardless of who's on the field.

Mike Evans · WR, SF

↓ Banged up and will be monitored early in the week, creating some concern for Brock Purdy's... wait, actually Tampa Bay context noted separately.

Harold Fannin · TE, CLE

↑ Caught 7 passes for 2 TDs, cementing himself as a strong weekly starter in the tier just below Bowers/McBride.

Christian Watson · WR, GB

↑ Playing as an alpha WR1 with back-to-back double-digit target games (7 catches, 96 yards, TD on 10 targets) amid Green Bay's pass-heavy funnel.

Marvin Harrison · WR, ARI

↓ Managers hoping for a trade given the crowded target competition, though the host doesn't see Arizona moving him.

Michael Wilson · WR, ARI

↑ Exploded for 17 targets and 26 PPR points, continuing a pattern of big games as Jacoby Brissett's favored secondary target.

Tyler Shough · QB, NO

↑ Threw 4 more TD passes, sitting around QB5 heading into Sunday Night Football despite a Saints loss, on pace to challenge Drew Brees' franchise TD records.

Sam Darnold · QB, SEA

↑ Threw for 379 yards and 4 TDs (with 2 INTs) in a comeback effort, showing the Klint Kubiak-style Brian Flurry offense is working for JSN.

MarShawn Lloyd · RB, GB

↓ Looking like a big bust after being a popular 7th-8th round draft pick, with the offensive line unable to block for him.

Matthew Golden · WR, GB

↑ Broke out with 5 catches, 100 yards, a TD and 12 targets, validating a preseason dynasty optimism that had drawn criticism.

Braelon Allen · RB, NYJ

↑ Recommended as the top waiver-wire pickup over Isaiah Davis if Breece Hall's injury sidelines him.

Michael Penix · QB, ATL

↑ Returned from injury and led Atlanta to a road upset over Green Bay, reviving the offense's outlook.

Kirk Cousins · QB, LV

↑ Has 9 passing TDs through 3 weeks as the Raiders went 3-0 under Clint Kubiak's play-calling, buying time before an eventual Fernando Mendoza transition.

Deshaun Watson · QB, CLE

→ Posted back-to-back low-end QB1 finishes, helping fuel a young Browns passing attack.

Michael Mayer · TE, LV

↑ Also scored a touchdown, forming a strong complementary TE duo with Bowers in Las Vegas.

Ollie Gordon · RB, MIA

↑ Looked good filling in and is the top waiver-wire pickup for the Dolphins backfield after Achane's injury.

← Back to the pods feed